Two stories, different outlooks on life with the happenings of post war and global terrorism.
We come to terms with a mother who looked
passed her child imperfections and saw nothing but a perfect baby but it is not
what it seems. In this story That
Only a Mother by Judith Merril (1948) shows the outcomes of radiation
and conception. Margaret, who is alone at home expecting a child and going
through a psychological battle with her thoughts is consumed by her thoughts
about her child, if she will become a mutant as other children that have been
born due to their partners working around radiation. There is some change of
location that we usually do not see much in the Sci-Fi genre which is a home as
many of us live in except it has technology related enhancements such as “On
the way to the kitchenette, she pressed the button that would start breakfast
cooking” (pg.212) now we all know we do not have a button that automatically
starts cooking our breakfast for us only in the sense you would see this in a
Sci-Fi story. Throughout the story Margaret is oblivious to the truth about her
child until the end when her husband finally meets their baby and sees that the
child does not have any limbs at all and goes into a “bitter spasm of
hysteria.” I’m assuming that as the other fathers who had mutant babies did was
being called “infanticides,” which is the mutant-children being killed by the
fathers but none have been convicted for it so at the end it seems the husband,
Hank, killed the child, “His fingers tightened on his child- oh god, she didn’t
know…” come to find out that while he was on duty his wife was making up this
perfect child up in her mind and writes to him about it. The only person in the
world that can see through all your imperfections and love you more than
anything is your mother and that is what we see here, she forgets the war, the
radiation-mutations and finds herself humble with the limbless child she has
and throughout the story when she reads about the mutations in Hiroshima she
keeps repeating to herself, “but my baby’s all right.” It was an interesting
take on this genre due to it did not have much science fiction tropes but you
can tell for its time it was in a future-like place.
In We
See Things Differently by Bruce
Sterling(1989), you see how the Arabs look at us in their eyes and it is
not a pretty sight, “the land of ignorance. This was America. The Great Satan,
the Arsenal of Imperialism, the Bankroller of Zionism, the Bastion of
Neo-Colonialism” (pg.612). This is how the Arab in the story thought about us
when he landed in Miami. To see how America is portrayed in this story is
horrifying but is it not where many people see us going? Now this story shows
many different things that we can all relate to seeing such as, the greed for money
that we can see in our society today, “It is very easy to buy Americans. The
mention of money brightens them like a shot of drugs” (pg.613). Sexuality is
depicted in this story as to show that the Arabs see us American women as sex
symbols for the American men, as he says “Like all American women, she was
dressed in a way intended to provoke lust.” It is a sad truth but is that not
how some women get what they want? like we say here in America “sex sells.” There is some hostility between the Americans
and foreigners in this story but as long as there is something in it for them
they throw that issue to the side. They speak of how America always was giving
away money and helping other countries out then they get the blame when Moscow was
blown up by some “Afghani terrorists,” Charlie persisted that the Americans had
something to do with Moscow. Towards the
end of the story Charlie basically sets up Boston by sharing some lethal
cocaine that was laced with a virus. In the story towards the end Charlie shows
that religion is why he did what he did to Boston and to himself he killed a
man for god. Now tell me what you think about this story it has more depth into
it than I can write about but I have my reasons for believing some of this as
well as other things but I am only human, so did this story really end on a
religious note or did it all come down terrorism?
UPDATE:
In class we went over these stories and our professor gave us an insight to the story "We See Things Differently" and she was telling us that Boston might have been the President in this time where politics and everything else is no longer standing but a Rocker who is well protected as a President would be as well as looked upon by the people the same way. If this is true than we see why Charlie shared the cocaine with him and basically killed him and it was all to keep America down when they were finally starting to get back on their feet slowly. The title of "That Only a Mother" is very ironic to the story because as the saying goes "he/she has a face that only a mother could love, in the story you see the denial that the mother has towards her daughter's mutation and still thinks she is perfect. These stories became more revealing when we discussed them more and depth and it is always interesting to see how my classmates perceive of the story and what they find that others did not notice.
UPDATE:
In class we went over these stories and our professor gave us an insight to the story "We See Things Differently" and she was telling us that Boston might have been the President in this time where politics and everything else is no longer standing but a Rocker who is well protected as a President would be as well as looked upon by the people the same way. If this is true than we see why Charlie shared the cocaine with him and basically killed him and it was all to keep America down when they were finally starting to get back on their feet slowly. The title of "That Only a Mother" is very ironic to the story because as the saying goes "he/she has a face that only a mother could love, in the story you see the denial that the mother has towards her daughter's mutation and still thinks she is perfect. These stories became more revealing when we discussed them more and depth and it is always interesting to see how my classmates perceive of the story and what they find that others did not notice.
Hey Priscilla ! I totally agree with your question because there are two point of views. To the arabs Charlie died a hero and it did end on a religious note for them. But to the Americans what he did was a terrorist attack because they were trying to rise again but he took their only hope they had. Its sad because the Arabs are kind of just looking out for themselves by making sure America stays down.
ReplyDeleteyes Alexandra I agree with you as well on those views. No matter what way you look at it in the end two people die for two different reasons and it is sad that it had to come to that but that is the price people now in days come across unfortunately especially during war.
ReplyDeletefor "That Only a Mother" I didn't think about the point of view you mentioned, it's true mothers see past all imperfections and deem their children as perfection. When Hank said "she doesn't know" maybe she actually did know and didn't see the problem, if that is the case I admire her for it.
ReplyDeleteI liked your perspective on both stories. You where able to tie them both together and show the correlation in both topics in the story. Little of an eye opener.
ReplyDelete